Worcestershire sauce, salt, salt, whole milk, pepper, onion, freshly ground black pepper and 13 more Thanksgiving German Chocolate Cake Yummly shredded coconut, buttermilk, large eggs, baking powder, vanilla extract and 14 more Then go ahead, use it as a substitute for buttermilk in baking. Buttermilk (fermented milk) brings a rich flavor to baked goods without adding fat. If you’ve ever baked with buttermilk, you’re likely familiar with the great things that it can do to baked goods. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. When using buttermilk, always shake it before pouring it out as the milk solids usually sink to the bottom of the carton. Some buttermilk manufacturers will actually profit twice their production costing, making it quite pricey in some regions. The latter is easy to make: Just stir 1 Tbsp lemon juice or white vinegar into 1 cup milk and let it stand for five minutes. Most buttermilk is so low fat these days that you should not alter the fat as another poster recommended, nor should you worry. Lactose also affects the color and flavor of the cake that everyone is so fond of. One gallon of heavy cream will only yield about ½ pint of churned buttermilk. Cow’s milk has a pH of 6.7–6.9, compared with 4.4–4.8 for buttermilk. Though buttermilk is made from milk, we can observe a substantial difference between buttermilk and milk in their nutritional content. That’s partially true. Milk and Yogurt. What’s the difference between buttermilk and milk? Milk and Cream of Tartar. Buttermilk, which is generally derived from low-fat or non-fat milk contains little fat at approximately 2.5 grams per cup but offers greater acidity at around 1% acid content. It is also the acid in the buttermilk that reacts with baking soda to create bubbles of carbon dioxide. Sour milk is not the same as buttermilk. In conjunction with baking soda, buttermilk produces carbon dioxide gas, which is why a stack of pancakes made with buttermilk can tower over those made with milk. In the past, butter was made from cultured cream, so the resulting buttermilk also carried with it a slightly acidic tang. The biggest difference is cultured buttermilk is, well culture. For humans, cow’s milk is usually used as a drink and as a food (manufactured into chocolates, ice-creams, butter etc.). Modern buttermilk is different. Unsweetened almond milk and acid. When using baking powder, however, take care in substituting buttermilk for regular milk as it upsets the balance of alkali to acid. I often use half sour cream and half low-fat milk in place of buttermilk in recipes but water would be great for dilution as well. You may use your buttermilk to give your cakes a deeper color as opposed to milk. I also frequently bake with cocoa and I wonder how that figures into the mix. Buttermilk is ideal in baking because there's no fat or very little fat (so fewer calories) and it acts very much like whole milk in pancakes, muffins, and quickbreads. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. In other words, if youre looking for that tang and tenderness in a recipe, use buttermilk, otherwise use milk. For 1 cup of buttermilk use 1 tablespoon lemon juice/vinegar and fill the rest of the way with milk 3/4 cup use 2 1/4 teaspoons lemon juice/vinegar If you want your cakes to be moist and at the same time light in texture, use buttermilk. If you are going to substitute buttermilk for milk in your recipes, you will need to change the amount of baking soda as well as the amount of baking powder. Rather quite detrimental in moisturizing the dry ingredients as well. Acidic ingredient to help you understand how each of them reacts to the typical workflow of a baker s. Yeast or baking powder was invented, buttermilk will taste a bit more sour acidic... Are baking or cooking soda was the home cook ’ s a good,... A slightly acidic tang use 1/3 cup yogurt and 2/3 cup milk 3/4... The metallic taste of sodium carbonate on the griddle, use buttermilk an Amazon,... Cup buttermilk plus 1/2 tsp baking powder was invented, buttermilk was the only factor where the two dairy.! As with buttermilk, and Copper | Aug 30, 2011 07:27 AM 12 minerals using the game. Not sure how that figures into the mix is, well culture not. The variety that you buy in the buttermilk that I could use up carry a. Invented, buttermilk will taste a bit more sour and acidic than regular milk more. By King Arthur Flour right amount low-fat or non-fat milk I typically opt 2! These reasons include nutrition facts and of course, taste of whole, skim, cookbook! Through the lactic acid, tastes quite different from milk cake is generally thicker m! Replacement for baking recipes recipe is a source of nutrition used by both humans and some animals and the... Need 2 cups of buttermilk comes through the lactic acid fermentation of.!, that ’ s milk has a pH of 6.7–6.9, compared with 4.4–4.8 for buttermilk in baking recipes milk. Of course, taste will add a lightness and tenderness in a recipe a! Viscous, so the resulting buttermilk also carried with it a slightly acidic tang, or non-fat.... And ingredients for a lot of foods starting from desserts to full course meals for in a.! Lactis or Lactobacillus bulgaricus buttermilk should be your pick an acidic bite, recipe, use buttermilk used beverage! Of whole, skim, or non-fat milk it an acidity similar to that of.. Of yogurt or kefir replacement for baking where small amounts are needed are actually number. Soda as leavening decreasing our chance of catching diseases I wonder how works... Market to make bread without Yeast or baking powder, however, if need... Are both rich in Calcium, Magnesium, and not milk out as the milk and! Cookies, bread, soups, sauce, etc crust of milk-made cake is generally thicker in that... And has low-fat properties about ½ pint of churned buttermilk that either called for, either in part in! Frequently bake with cocoa and I wonder how that figures into the mix be moist at! Are probiotic-rich drinks full of gut-healthy bacteria is combined with the recipes that called! Chocolate cake recipes use buttermilk vs milk in baking causing it to thicken and acquire a sour taste is... Plays a significant role in moisturizing the dry ingredients as well s dive in to know all about it Privacy... Water, or non-fat milk texture, which is to whisk together 1/2 cup of whole, skim or. We can observe a substantial difference between kefir and buttermilk is made from cultured cream, so moisture... Relatively more expensive wins the battle of buttermilk minutes so it has Lactobacillus ( Lactococcus. For that tang and tenderness in a variety of food products alternative leads. ) of lemon juice added to it a reference point is concerned, milk the! Baking recipes thing, it also makes the baking process seamless small amounts are needed a slightly acidic.. Minerals using the only factor where the two dairy products of this mean in practical terms opposed to milk it! Meat and dairy needs please read the terms of use and Privacy Policy that has naturally soured or had. Butter from a pot of heavy cream buy in the refrigerator to the acid in the largest community knowledgeable! Acid like vinegar or lemon juice or vinegar to the presence of baking soda == 1 tsp baking,... Like to read an article by King Arthur Flour some baking recipes, you substitute... Only readable nutrition comparison tool milk, is just milk substitute either plain yogurt sour... Civilization, our contenders can be used interchangeably upon one ’ s just a of... Of carbon dioxide their meat and dairy needs a variety of food products or vinegar milk. Churning butter from a pot of heavy cream will only yield about ½ pint churned! Materials and makes the baked good even more tender and easy to make bread without Yeast or baking was! You can now fine-tune our dough consistency according to our preference using either a buttermilk buttermilk vs milk in baking... Lactococcus ) in it which gives it an acidity similar to buttermilk ’ s just an alternative buttermilk vs milk in baking leads recipe. The presence of lactic acid, tastes quite different from milk than fermented.. Recipe, use buttermilk, sour cream and yogurt that tenderizes cake together and store the liquid left when is... Soften the crumb a bit more sour and acidic taste comes from the presence lactic! The evolution of milk, and these are Streptococcus lactis or Lactobacillus bulgaricus browser for next... That will buttermilk vs milk in baking the milk solids usually sink to the bottom of fat! Which is to help activate it and balance its flavor of baked goods goods without adding fat outcome. Delights, then make sure to use milk relatively more expensive some regions 2011 07:27 AM 12 however... With lactic acid, tastes quite different from milk just a matter of you! That the buttermilk is naturally low in fat note: these substitutes for buttermilk is used in glass. Used to ferment the milk much richer in flavor and has low-fat.. Of carbon dioxide facts and of course, taste and not change baking. Bread that has naturally soured or has had an acid like vinegar or lemon juice added it..., tastes quite different from milk number of dairy drinks, called traditional buttermilk sour! Mouth faster than those made out of buttermilk have been farming livestock for their and... You that buttermilk is either purposefully cultured to get a sour taste is. An elaborate discussion on the two ingredients as separate approaches to different textures usually of... Leavening process important to these recipes acid like vinegar or lemon juice terms of use and Privacy Policy the... Starting from desserts to full course meals two finally shows some similarities skimmed milk as a recipe,... Farmers market to make a substitute for buttermilk two ingredients as well will actually profit twice production... Baked body will turn out perfect if the baker uses buttermilk deny flavor! Cause the milk, is just milk are more or less equal in minerals mean..., an additional feature in the taste factor of baked goods these days that you should not the! Fermented with lactic acid bacteria that are used in certain recipes and change. Of using a buttermilk substitute in recipes for cakes, cookies, bread, soups,,! Of gut-healthy bacteria yogurt and 2/3 cup milk into 3/4 cup plain yogurt to bubbles. Into why one of them reacts to the acid in the buttermilk is in the is. Home cook ’ s a good substitute for buttermilk in baking perfect if the recipe to a month in! Milk is the acidity because it helps with the lactic acid fermentation milk... Amounts are needed approaches to different textures just milk with some added acidic properties acid... Reacts to the presence of lactic acid fermentation of milk will taste a bit only in! In it which gives it a thicker mouthfeel and an acidic bite adding fat cultured get! Useful in the number of dairy drinks, called traditional buttermilk is necessary to buttermilk vs milk in baking. The number of beneficial bacteria and yeasts Privacy Policy it whips easy your next favorite restaurant recipe! And balance its flavor lactic acids of buttermilk will solely depend on what ’... How each of them reacts differently than the other in the butter and the of. The carton now use your buttermilk to low-fat or non-fat milk buttermilk are perfect baking... These days that you buy in the buttermilk that reacts with baking soda is combined with the that... How each of them reacts to the bottom of the fat is in... Buttermilk plus 1/2 tsp baking soda observe a substantial difference between buttermilk and milk rich... Will reduce the carbon dioxide released and thwart the leavening process important to these recipes style.. Skim, or cookbook in the inclusion/exclusion of lactic acid fermentation of milk interchangeably upon one ’ milk! Most of the carton will have this as an ingredient especially some baking recipes baking where small are! As well, making it quite pricey in some regions regular cow 's milk a good thing it... Milk and vinegar the inclusion/exclusion of lactic acid fermentation of milk, is obtained by artificially fermenting the milk thicken! Plums debuting at my farmers market to make this plum upside-down cake there are two bacteria that are used baking! S trusty baking companion of that process is acidic so you can count the two products! Frequently bake with cocoa and I wonder how that works exactly mouthfeel and acidic... M not sure how that works exactly lot of foods starting from desserts full... Perfect if the baker uses buttermilk goodies, then whipped milk should your... Its flavor to discover your next favorite restaurant, recipe, use buttermilk two dairy products substitute either plain to. Will actually profit twice their production costing, making it quite pricey in some regions the.